Acoustic or Electric Guitar for Beginners: Which Should You Choose?

One of the questions I hear most often from people buying their first guitar is, “Should I start on an acoustic or an electric?”

My advice is simple: start with the type of guitar that makes you want to play.

You don’t need to learn acoustic before moving to electric. Equally, an acoustic guitar isn’t just a stepping stone to something else. Both are wonderful instruments, and the right choice depends on the music you enjoy, what feels comfortable and how you imagine yourself playing.

Start with the music you love

If you picture yourself strumming chords and singing along to your favourite songs, an acoustic guitar could be exactly what you need.

If it’s electric guitar sounds that excite you, whether that’s blues, rock, indie or clean melodic playing, there is absolutely no reason not to start on an electric.

The guitar that inspires you is the one you’re more likely to pick up tomorrow. That matters far more than somebody telling you what a beginner is “supposed” to play.

Is an acoustic guitar easier for a beginner?

An acoustic is simpler to get started with in one practical sense: you can pick it up and play without an amplifier.

That makes it a lovely option if you want to practise around the house, accompany your singing or keep the equipment to a minimum.

However, acoustic guitars typically use heavier strings than electric guitars. Depending on the instrument and its setup, pressing those strings down can take more effort.

Body size matters too. A large dreadnought might sound wonderful, but a smaller-bodied acoustic may feel more comfortable to hold. Bigger doesn’t automatically mean better, especially when you’re learning.

Explore my recommended acoustic guitars for beginners

Is an electric guitar easier on your fingers?

Often, yes. Electric guitars typically have lighter strings, which can make fretting your first notes and chords less physically demanding.

Their bodies are also generally thinner than an acoustic guitar’s, although weight and balance vary considerably between models.

You will normally want an amplifier or a suitable headphone practice device to hear the electric guitar as intended. That adds something to your budget, but it also gives you the opportunity to explore different sounds.

Don’t assume that electric means loud! With suitable equipment, headphone practice can be a very practical option when you share your home with other people.

Explore my recommended electric guitars for beginners

What about a nylon-string guitar?

A nylon-string guitar is another option, particularly if you love classical, Spanish or fingerstyle music.

Nylon strings can feel gentler on your fingertips than steel strings. However, traditional classical guitars generally have wider necks, which can make some stretches more demanding.

I wouldn’t recommend choosing nylon strings purely because somebody says they are “for beginners”. Choose the instrument because its sound, feel and musical purpose suit you.

If you’re unsure, ask us. A short conversation about what you want to play can make the choice much clearer.

The detail I would never overlook: the setup

Whatever type you choose, how the guitar is set up can make a huge difference to your first experience.

The action is the distance between the strings and the frets. If the strings sit unnecessarily high, you have to work harder to press them down. If they sit too low for the instrument and your playing style, you can run into unwanted buzzing.

A proper setup involves balancing those details so the guitar plays comfortably and responds as it should.

It won’t remove the need to practise, and some fingertip tenderness is normal when you start. But you shouldn’t have to fight an instrument that is making learning harder than necessary.

This is why our workshop preparation is such an important part of what we do. We include our Custom Pro Setup & Support Package with every guitar purchase.

How much should you spend on your first guitar?

I would focus on buying a dependable, comfortable instrument rather than finding the cheapest possible guitar or spending as much as you can afford.

An expensive guitar isn’t a requirement for learning. What matters is that it stays in tune reliably, feels manageable and sounds good enough to encourage you.

Think about the complete cost, too:

• Acoustic guitar: allow for a tuner, picks and a suitable bag if you need to transport it.

• Electric guitar: allow for an amplifier or headphone practice device, the appropriate cable and any other essentials.

• Either type: a strap and stand may be useful, depending on how and where you practise.

Check what is included before buying a package. A bundle only represents good value if the guitar and the accessories are things you actually need.

Buying for a child? Check the fit first

Age-based size guides can be a starting point, but children of the same age can have very different reaches and hand sizes.

The important questions are whether they can hold the guitar comfortably, reach the neck and use both hands without struggling around an oversized body.

Don’t assume that a small adult guitar, a travel guitar and a child’s guitar are interchangeable. Ask for guidance before choosing.

My recommendation